25 Comments
User's avatar
Mariella Hunt's avatar

I love this so much. I also am fascinated by the mermaid myth, how worldwide it is; I’ve been writing a series based on mermaids and lies made up about them. I’m currently editing book 3.

It’s true - they will lie to make us look like Ursulas.

They don’t realize that Ursula isn’t a bad person to be. I think that, in my adult life, I’ve sort of admired her more!

Great post!

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Oh that is so cool Mariella! What is the name of the series? I’d love to check it out! It means even more that you enjoyed my piece as an expert on the subject! 💕

Expand full comment
Mariella Hunt's avatar

Haha I wouldn’t call myself an expert, just slightly obsessed since childhood!

The first two books are called The Sea Rose and The Sea King :)

Expand full comment
invisiblegirl's avatar

"their tails forbade penetration". why haven't i thought of it like that before!

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Right?! Like talk about an unlikely sex symbol!

Expand full comment
Tasha Dawn's avatar

"They had the power to sink or save an entire ship. They did not need men. And, in fact, men needed them." So true!!!

Here in Nova Scotia there are stories of selkies... I've always believed in mermaids and selkies. Like your observations of men needing mermaids, the same could be said for selkies. I love the idea of reclaiming these beautiful mythical creatures with all our womenly power!

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Thank you so much Tasha! I am fascinated by selkies too! Maybe I'll write a piece about them next! I'm in North Carolina, and I love that you're reading this in Nova Scotia - Substack is amazing :)

Expand full comment
cosi’s odyssey's avatar

Just sensational 🐚 I particularly loved learning about Atargatis, I’ve never come across her before.

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Thank you so much! And right?! Atargatis is so badass!

Expand full comment
Kassi Wilson's avatar

I love your publication! I think you're really on to something, fairy tales, the way they should be told! Great topic to delve into. Wondering if you've read "Women Who Run With The Wolves"

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Thank you so much for your kind words! And yes, I have read it -- the themes and topics were so fascinating! I got so many great ideas from it, but I will say I thought some of her chapters could have been a bit more succinct haha!

Expand full comment
Kassi Wilson's avatar

I agree, chapters got long.

Expand full comment
Moves to Master's avatar

Highly recommend everyone check out the Museum of the Bizarre in Wilmington. You won't be able to forget this terrifying mermaid. Great post!

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

haha thank you random guy on internet! I'm so glad you loved my piece enough to visit this museum!

Expand full comment
Debbie Liu's avatar

A powerful piece, evoking the violence done against women through mythology, then in real life with the barnum circus, and again in real life to your young self. Now it's happening again / still, with the advent of a. i. Keep splashing around with your mermaid tale.

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Wow thank you so much Debbie for your thoughtful comment! And yes, it really is crazy how this cycle never seems to let up. We just have to keep swimming against the current!

Expand full comment
Lee West's avatar

Cool interpretation of the myth, albeit a bitter one. Mermaids are such an enchanting allegory, a twist on the predator/prey gender archetypes, but also so appropriate to how helpless lonely explorers feel—how terrified men are of seduction, know all the warning signs, and still crave it to their own demise.

Expand full comment
Roberta's avatar

I am obsessed!!! This is so so good

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Thank you so much Roberta!! It was sooo fun to research

Expand full comment
Lia💓's avatar

i looove this article! gave me a whole new perspective on mermaids & so much info on their history. Amazing

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Aww Lia, I'm so glad you enjoyed this and learned something new - that is always my goal with every essay I post!

Expand full comment
Jody's avatar

Long obsessed with mermaids, since Splash! Great piece.

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

So glad you enjoyed it!

Expand full comment
julie radford's avatar

This is so well researched and written and I love every word 😭🖤

Expand full comment
Caroline Beuley's avatar

Thank you so much Julie!!

Expand full comment